We’ve all been told that a perfect 4.0 CGPA is the gold standard of student excellence. It’s supposed to signify a sharp mind, an impeccable work ethic, and a future-ready professional. But lately, I’ve come to realize a frustrating truth: a perfect GPA cannot buy humility, efficiency, or basic respect.
If you’ve ever mentored an undergraduate student who managed to combine weaponized incompetence with an astonishing layer of entitlement, grab a coffee. This one is for you.
📱 The Infinite Loop of Telegram Receipts
There is a unique kind of exhaustion that comes from pointing out the exact same correction more than once. I didn't just give feedback casually; I laid it out clearly, both verbally during face-to-face discussions and written down in black and white on Telegram.
Yet, like clockwork, the exact same mistakes reappeared every single time.
Eventually, I had to escalate the issue to the student’s supervisor. Initially, the supervisor simply advised me to keep pushing and "berate" the student into compliance. But it shouldn't take parental scolding to get a final-year student to follow basic instructions.
🤯 The Audacity: Raising Voices & The "Mother Tongue" Defense
The turning point came when the supervisor finally saw the reality with his own eyes noon 3 July 2026. During a confrontation, this undergraduate foreigner male student actually raised his voice at me, blaming me for criticizing his badly translated Bahasa Melayu abstract.
His grand defense? Bahasa Melayu isn't his mother tongue. Let’s look at the facts: This student is in his fourth year in Malaysia. The BM abstract is not an optional creative writing exercise. It is a compulsory, strict requirement for graduation.
My response to him was simple, quiet, and direct: "This is your thesis, and these are your marks. I am helping you out for free, all while managing my own workload at the same time." I had even spent my personal time the previous day sending detailed comments on his draft. The entitlement was staggering.
⏰ The 4:00 PM Breaking Point
The final showdown happened over a required flowchart. I had clearly informed the student before noon that I would be leaving the office by 5:00 PM that day.
At 4:00 PM, with only one hour left on the clock, the student casually informed me that he would do the flowchart "later." That was the absolute last straw for his supervisor, who finally stepped in and completely lashed out at him for his total lack of time management.
Even after that blast, the student was still asking me about basic spacing rules before citation brackets, specifically, the spaces before a `[?]`.
●The Available Resource: I had repeatedly told him to refer directly to the official UTM thesis format available on the university website.
●The Inefficient Workflow: When I finally told him to open the formatting guide right then and there, he opened the files one by one, closing one to look at the other. Instead of simply placing the documents side-by-side on his screen for a split-second visual comparison, he dragged out a two-minute task into an painful ordeal.
This is a 4.0 CGPA student. Let that sink in.
If a student at the absolute top of the grading scale displays an improper, inefficient workflow and throws a tantrum when held accountable, try to imagine what we are facing with the non-4.0 pool. I have guided plenty of undergraduate students before him and taken the time to explain these exact processes, yet this "perfect" student was undeniably the worst.
High grades might open doors, but true competence is measured by how you handle feedback, how efficiently you work, and how you treat the people who are helping you succeed for free. This is where shows how important to have good knowledgeable on situational awareness, manners, empathy and ethics
No comments:
Post a Comment